With youth video self-tape submissions extended until Tuesday 17 November 2026 at 5:00 PM and adult in-person auditions commencing the week of Tuesday 17 November 2026 at North Ryde School of the Arts for the 2027 New South Wales Premiere of Finding Neverland at The Concourse Theatre in Chatswood (19 February to 7 March 2027), our creative panel sat down to share exactly what we look for in the audition room. Fresh from conducting our 23-piece live symphony orchestra on Disney's Frozen, Music Director David Catterall (joined on the music team by Assistant Music Director Cass Donovan) breaks down his 6 core vocal audition tips.
01. What Makes the Panel Sit Up in the First 10 Seconds?
Before you even sing your first note, the way you treat the rehearsal pianist sets the tone for your entire audition. As David explains:
“Acknowledge the accompanist, introduce yourself to them, and explain your clearly marked score in detail with them. Don't assume the accompanist already knows your song no matter how popular you may think it is. Introduce it to them like it's brand new.” – David Catterall, Music Director
Make sure your sheet music is placed in a matte plastic display folder or taped cleanly so pages do not fall off the music stand mid-phrase, with your starting bar, tempo, any cuts, and your ending bar clearly highlighted.
02. The #1 Overdone Audition Song to Avoid
When we asked David if there is one audition song he would happily retire after sitting through hundreds of Sydney musical theatre auditions, his answer was immediate:
“I love 'Journey to the Past' as much as anyone, but after hearing it 12 times during Frozen auditions, I will gratefully listen to anything else. Try me.” – David Catterall, Music Director
For Finding Neverland, Composer Gary Barlow OBE and Eliot Kennedy wrote a soaring contemporary pop-theatre and Edwardian orchestral score. Choose a 60 to 90 second piece that reflects the world of the show and shows off your authentic vocal colour rather than picking the most common audition ballad in Sydney.
03. How to Pick Your 60 to 90 Second Song Cut
Many singers make the mistake of cutting straight to the final eight bars of a song to prove they can hit a money note cold. David advises building a runway into your cut:
“Don't dive straight into the deep end, as your nerves won't do you any favours. Start with a comfortable section before leading into the vocal peak of the cut.” – David Catterall, Music Director
Starting four to eight bars before the bridge or chorus gives your breath a moment to settle with the piano, allows the panel to hear your conversational middle register, and makes the vocal climax feel earned.
04. High Notes vs. Storytelling (And If You Lose Your Spot)
What actually goes through the panel's head when someone hits a massive belt note versus when they genuinely act the lyric? And what happens if nerves strike and you blank on a lyric at the piano?
“Range and vocal ability are assumed. Storytelling takes it to the next level. If there's an opportunity to make us laugh, do it. The panel will connect with how you made them feel in the room. And I personally don't mind if someone restarts their song if I can tell you know it. If you're fumbling because you don't know your lyrics, that's a different problem. I'm not personally judging you on your memory in the audition room.” – David Catterall, Music Director
Co-Director Rodrigo Medina Noel echoes that exact sentiment from the directing desk: “Start by speaking the lyrics. Who are you talking to, and what do you need from them? Trying to make every moment impressive, where every word gets a gesture and every line gets a face, makes you lose what you're actually saying. Trust the material, keep things simple, and come ready to play.”
05. Filming a Youth Self-Tape at Home (For the Four Llewelyn Davies Boys)
For round one of our youth auditions (casting two alternating teams of young actors aged 8 to 14 to play Peter, George, Jack, and Michael Llewelyn Davies), all submissions are via video self-tape, now extended until Tuesday 17 November 2026 at 5:00 PM. Here is David's advice for parents and young performers filming at home:
“Watch self-tapes on YouTube to see what works, and don't worry about small mistakes. We're looking at the overall package, not perfection.” – David Catterall, Music Director
06. Why Our Ensemble & Specialist Dancers Get the Biggest Numbers in the Show
If you are in your late teens, twenties, or thirties and wondering where you fit between the adult leads and the four young brothers, do not overlook the Ensemble, the Pomeroy Acting Troupe, the Pirate Chorus, and Choreographer Janina Hamerlok's Specialist Dance Ensemble (featuring 8 female and 4 male strong dancers who also sing):
“Some of Gary Barlow's biggest pop-rock anthems in Finding Neverland ('Stronger', 'Live by the Hook', 'Play') belong to our Pirate Chorus and Pomeroy Acting Troupe.” – David Catterall, Music Director
Ready to Step Into the Audition Room for Finding Neverland?
Book your in-person vocal audition slot at North Ryde School of the Arts or upload a youth self-tape via our official Audition Portal.
Book 2027 Audition Slot →Auditions & Role Briefs →Explore Finding Neverland →

